Who wins? M@ vs. Mr. JDM

[M@]

M@'s entry:

http://www.eyeheartboost.com/photoshop/gticomp/gti.jpg

Mr. JDM's entry:

http://x11.putfile.com/4/10922472387.jpg

[frog37_]

Overall i give it to m@

It seems all JDM did was change the wheels, color, and background

where m@'s has more small details that were not overlooked (for instance the reflection of the different wheels)

[Slow96GSR]

I voted for M@. Even though JDM did a very nice job, he forgot a little red in the front grill.

I have to vote for mine though!!

http://www.strathlan.com/CMS/images/vwgolf.jpg

[Steve_C]

Add vietnamese sammiches to the poll and i'll cast my vote!!

[Mr. JDM]

I didnt forget red on the grill. Look at M@'s . Thats how the grill is.


Someone set up a new contest for anyone to join.

[oldskoolracer]

m@ did all the nice deatails but, mr.jdm's just looks hawt.


hard to decide it's nice either way you go.
and i do see m@ grill the color doesn't match the rest of the car and yours has a small line of red but the could be the GTI red like on the side moldings of the older ones, that's my .2

[john]

They both suck.

[Dave_L]

I voted for M@'s because of all the little details like the change in grill emblems. Although, I like Mr. JDM's wheels better.

[redb20teg]

They both suck.

+1




j/k theyre ok

[M@]

I didnt forget red on the grill. Look at M@'s . Thats how the grill is.
There isn't a speck of red on the rest of your car. It's ok, man.. you can admit you suck.

[oldskoolracer]

There isn't a speck of red on the rest of your car. It's ok, man.. you can admit you suck.


;NutKick; :rofl:

[M@]

By the way.. for those of you curious WTF my license plate means, "TTUZA"...

Time To Unpimp Zee Auto

[nxbrennan]

Mr. JDM definitely. M@'s major changes (wheels, intercooler) look totally fake. Doing a few smaller details won't make up for that.

Although Mr. JDM, why do you keep picking poop mixed with vomit colors for your chops?

[M@]

However, he did forget some major details.. reflection of the wheels, big red spot in the grille... lol. His is still nice none the less. :)

[STIBungy]

I voted MrJDM's.

Pros for MrJDM:
air dam blends in well
wheels
shaved molding
intercooler integrated nicely into front bumper

Cons for MrJDM:
wheels are too deep, looks unrealistic
red insert on grill doesnt match anything
color is questionable
amber corner lights dont blend in well

Pros for M@:
brake calipers display nicely
shaved door handles
shaved molding
shadowing

Cons for M@:
wheels dont blend in well with body of car. Easily looks cut n pasted on
tinted windows
color-matched underbody
original badge mark on hood
TTUZA doesnt blend into plates well
FMIC looks cut n pasted on

[M@]

You're entitled to your opinion, but I personally think you're on crack about the FMIC and the underbody. Thanks for your input though. :)

[Brandon]

Didn't vote. I think JDM did better chopping but shit brown doesn't get a vote.

JDM's: rear tire has an angle where it meets the ground. Cool wheels. Good job paint matching the side skirts. Nice sky. I prefer the stock clears over the ambers. Front lip was a nice addition but doesn't look good, drivers side hangs lower and the blending on the pass. could've been better.

M@: Side skirt coloring doesn't look right, there should be shadows on the pass. side on the bottom. Nice reflection on the new wheels. The hood should be straight without the little cut out from the old logo. Coloring needs to be better on the lip.

Yep, I've got nothing better to do right now than pick these apart :)

[STIBungy]

The sideskirt looks brighter than the rest of the car.

You're entitled to your opinion, but I personally think you're on crack about the FMIC and the underbody. Thanks for your input though. :)

[M@]

B - I considered the hood thing, but also consider this.. in real life if someone debadged that, that's how it would look. The only way to eliminate that in real life would be to get a custom hood.

[Slow96GSR]

They are both good. They can do 1 thing I can't, for now, and that makes them good in my book!

[oldskoolracer]

that's not brown it a green like that bmw green i think

i like the color more than the stock red

[HondaPower]

We got a tie.

[ChewiSi]

M@'s b/c of the finer details.

[M@]

We got a tie.
Actually looks like I have another win under my belt. ;)

[Nightfall]

You guys should chop something that isn't an automobile, see who is *really* good at photoshop ;)
Not just using the same photoshop techniques over and over.

[Mr. JDM]

You mean something like this. I did this for a friend of mine a few month ago.

Original
http://x11.putfile.com/4/11100160258.jpg
After
http://x11.putfile.com/4/11100165451.jpg

I could probly do it alot better now.

[-=[Juztin]=-]

I like the JDM car more just because the overall color scheme and tire really compliment each other. Also simpler is sometimes better, and I think the stock grill 'n all keeps it cleaner and lets you focus on the car's profile and the rim style which match great. The IC being obvious would probably not look bad at all, but kinda breaks it up rather than bringing it all together.

[M@]

Mr. JDM, why does that little girl have arms growing from her arms?! :D :rofl: That looks ultra creepy.

[chris_venturini]

its the ring!!!

[Zach]

Mr. JDM's is much better.

even though m@ changed things like the grill emblem, he should have smoothed out where teh VW was, instead of leaving a semi circle of black grill.

plus all he did was add wheels (which look hella fake. even though they both do, m@'s are just obvious.) and color match the trim and lip (which actually looks like a different color entirely.

MR. JDM's car flows really well. plus his stuff doesnt look obvious, and everything complements everything else.

edit: plus i think the red stripe in the grill looks cool with the rest of the car.

[Richard T]

IMO, M@ got smoked this time. Still don't get some of Mr.JDM's color choices, however.

[M@]

All tied up! This has been going back and forth all weekend.. lol.

[Mr. JDM]

I pick odd colors cuz I like to have colors noone else has. Thats what makes a car unique

[ripperbone]

M@'s looks way better! M@ did more work to his chop like adding the FMIC, rotors and calipers, windowtint, changed the vw grill to a rabbit grill, smoking the lights in the mirror.

Mr. JDM just changed the rims, added clouds, and the color of the car, pretty much not much work on the chop IMO

[nxbrennan]

JDM did an fmic too, its just not as blatant.

[M@]

Some people like IC's to be bold and obvious, some like them to be hidden and sleeper; to each their own.

[Mr. JDM]

I guess I win?

[M@]

Says who? I had the lead all weekend til about 5:00 pm yesterday by about 4 or 5 votes, but whatev. I don't care either way.. I'll actually try in the next one just to be sure I rock you.

[Skaterkid]

More M@ excuses "On the next one, I'll try", "Boy if I had put more than an hour in this one...."

I vote Mr JDM, and M@ learn to take a loss like a man and not make up excuses like you do for everything.

[LeonZ]

JDM cuz it doesn't suck ballz.

[M@]

More M@ excuses "On the next one, I'll try", "Boy if I had put more than an hour in this one...."

I vote Mr JDM, and M@ learn to take a loss like a man and not make up excuses like you do for everything.
No thanks, I think I'll keep pissing you all off. :)

[Mr. JDM]

Says who? I had the lead all weekend til about 5:00 pm yesterday by about 4 or 5 votes, but whatev. I don't care either way.. I'll actually try in the next one just to be sure I rock you.


Doesnt matter if you win by an inch or a mile winnings winning.




(Didnt think id ever get to say that)

PS (Didnt think id ever quote that movie :/ )

[M@]

Congrats on your win.

[Mr. JDM]

How bout another. Someone other then me and M@ set up another contest for anyone to join.

[Conrad]

How bout another. Someone other then me and M@ set up another contest for anyone to join.

You guys are worse then attn whores....

[oldskoolracer]

:rofl:

[M@]

You guys are worse then attn whores....
End yourself.

[Conrad]

End yourself.

leave hai again.

[M@]

leave hai again.
Go get blinded again.

[Conrad]

Go get blinded again.

go buy some more green wire!

[M@]

go buy some more green wire!
Nothing a little electrical tape/wire tucking can't cover up.

[M@]

Oh my god.. who's the retarded person that just voted on a 3 month old poll?

[Deceptakhan]

nice job on the little things m@

[blackciv4]

Yet again....

[M@]

Yet again....
lol. No shit.

[allmotorH22]

thats all you matt

[Weston]

Ugh... this thread needs to die. No one even cared in the first place.

[M@]

lol.

[M@]

http://manmadedesigns.com/forumcrap/Bad%20Thread/fdeaf9cb%5b1%5d.jpg

[doogie06]

I went with M@, although I think JDM's car looks very good, I like the color better, but as far as who did the most with the car, M@ did.

[Terry]

Your opinion does not count Doog

[doogie06]

I figured as much.

[mista_tuan]

m@ cuz he did a little more detailing, plus he has the gofast little doot!

[floored4door]

m@ cuz he did a little more detailing, plus he has the gofast little doot!


whats a doot? Its a rabbit n00b!

[mista_tuan]

doot = dude and im no nub fool!

[floored4door]

oh thats right, 8 posts make you an OG.

[M@]

Ohnoes!!1 There's about to be a whaaaat?

[mista_tuan]

alright man u just take this shit waaay to serious!

[Terry]

Oh no its fight time

[M@]

I'll get the K-Y.